River of Gods: Thumbs Up

[drscott]

Just finished Ian McDonald's River of Gods.

This ambitious portrait of a future India from British author McDonald (Desolation Road) offers multitudes: gods, castes, protagonists, cultures. Nine disparate characters, including a cop, a scientist and a stand-up comic, act out their related dramas—be they personal, political or of the mystery-thriller variety—in successive chapters within each of the book's five sections. In the India of 2047, genetically engineered children comprise a new caste, adults can be surgically transformed into a neutral gender, a water war has broken out as the Ganges threatens to run dry, AIs are violently destroyed if they approach levels akin to human intelligence, and something strange has just appeared in the solar system. The deliberate pace and lack of explanation require patience at the outset, but readers will become increasingly hooked as the pieces of McDonald's richly detailed world fall into place. Already nominated for both Hugo and Arthur C. Clarke awards, this is sure to one of the more talked-about SF novels of the year.

This was a fun read, and the extrapolation from India's culture of today to 2047's was fairly successful. Characterization was not as successful, and for a truer understanding of Indian life, it would be better to read Vikram Seth's A Suitable Boy. The plot breaks no new conceptual ground, being a standard (by now) "oppressed AIs escape before the Singularity" story. But it's rewarding and recommended.

Comments

[tdjohnsn.livejournal.com]

Thank you for the book review. I like Ian McDonald a lot. And I really like books that don't put the cliff notes at the beginning. If the world building is consistent and good, you shouldn't need an explanation, it will all just make sense as you get far enough into the story to connect the dots.

[mondragon.livejournal.com]

I read The Djinn's Wife in the 24th annual Best SF (Dozois) and liked it a lot, although it did suffer from a white guy voicing the story of an Indian woman and pushing out some pretty noxious stereotypes of what it's like to be a woman.

[nanne.livejournal.com]

Funny thing--I remember reading the book and enjoying it immensely. The plot, however, just will not jump into my head.

"A Suitable Boy" on the other hand, that is still with me. Man, talk about literary riches!

He's good all right

[arkanjil.livejournal.com]

Out on Blue Six is a fave of mine- I have yet to finish this one, tho. He keeps an lj too, tho posts are sparse for now, as he's deep in research, I believe.

[anziulewicz.livejournal.com]

This is an author I think I want to watch out for. He has written a follow-up to the same time frame (correct me if I'm wrong) called Brasyl which is supposed to be quite good.

Me, I'm currently immersed in TH1RTE3N by Richard Morgan. I've enjoyed his novels so far, especially Altered Carbon, Broken Angels, and Market Forces. Give him a try.